---
title: "What to Look For in a Marketing Agency (Scorecard)"
url: https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency
description: "What to look for in a marketing agency: 10 criteria, the questions to ask, red flags, contract terms to check, and a free scorecard to compare agencies."
lang: en
---

Image: Lucid Brands Home (https://lucidbrands.agency/img/logo.svg)

©Lucid Brands 2026

Close article: https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency

Image: Working With an Agency resource article: What to Look For in a Marketing Agency (https://lucidbrands.agency/media/resources/art-what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency.jpg)

# What to Look For in a Marketing Agency

Look for an agency that asks about your business before it pitches tactics, shows results for companies like yours, names the people who will do the work, and reports on leads and revenue rather than likes. Then check the contract: you should own your ad accounts, analytics and data, and be able to leave with 30 days notice.

## The short answer

The right marketing agency is clear on five things: what it will do, who will do it, what it costs, how success is measured, and what happens if you part ways. If any of those are vague in the proposal, they will be vague in the work.

## Before you look: three things to decide

1. **Your goal.** More calls, more booked appointments, more online sales, or a new market. Pick one main goal for the first six months.
2. **Your budget.** Separate the agency fee from ad spend. A $3,000 total budget is very different from $3,000 in fees plus $5,000 in ads.
3. **The type of help you need.** A specialist agency is best when one channel matters most, such as Google Ads or SEO. A full-service agency is better when you need several channels to work together.

## Ten things to look for

## 1. Questions before answers

A good agency spends the first call learning your margins, your best customers, your sales process and what has failed before. A weak one jumps straight to "you need TikTok."

## 2. Proof from businesses like yours

Ask for two or three case studies in your industry or with a similar sales cycle. Look for the starting point, what changed, the timeline and the result in leads or revenue.

## 3. The people on your account

You should meet the strategist and the specialists who will do the work, not only the founder or salesperson.

## 4. A written plan

The proposal should list channels, deliverables, timelines and targets for the first 90 days. If it reads like it could be sent to any company, it probably was.

## 5. Reporting on business results

Reports should show spend, leads, cost per lead, booked calls or sales, and next steps. Impressions and followers are supporting numbers, not the goal.

## 6. Transparent pricing

You should know the monthly fee, what it covers, and what costs extra. Ask whether ad spend is billed by the platform directly or passed through with a markup.

## 7. You own the accounts

Your Google Ads, Meta Ads, Google Analytics, Google Business Profile, website and CRM should be in your business name with the agency added as a user.

## 8. Current skills

Search is changing fast. Ask how the agency handles Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT search, privacy changes and first party data.

## 9. Clear communication

Agree on a main contact, a meeting rhythm and a response time. Weekly or biweekly calls are normal for active campaigns.

## 10. Fair terms

Look for month to month terms or a short minimum, a 30 day exit clause, and no fees for handing back your assets.

## The agency scorecard

Score each agency from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) on every line. Multiply by the weight and add up the total. The highest score out of 100 wins.

| Criterion | Weight | What a 5 looks like |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Understands our business | 3 | Asked about margins, customers and sales process |
| Relevant results | 3 | Two or more case studies with real numbers |
| Team we will work with | 2 | Met the people doing the work |
| Written 90 day plan | 2 | Channels, deliverables, targets and dates |
| Reporting | 2 | Leads, cost per lead and revenue, monthly at least |
| Pricing clarity | 2 | Fee, scope and extras in writing |
| Account ownership | 2 | Everything in our name |
| Current skills | 1 | Clear answer on AI search and tracking |
| Communication | 1 | Named contact and meeting rhythm |
| Contract terms | 2 | Short minimum, 30 day exit |

## Questions to ask on the first call

- Who exactly will work on our account, and how many other clients do they have?
- What would you do in the first 30, 60 and 90 days?
- Which numbers will you report on, and how often?
- Can you show a result for a business with our budget, not only your biggest client?
- What do you need from us each week to make this work?
- How do you bill ad spend? Is there a markup?
- Do you outsource any of the work? If so, to whom?
- What happens to our accounts and files if we leave?
- What is something you would tell us not to do?

## Red flags

- Guaranteed rankings or a guaranteed number of leads.
- Ad accounts or the website built in the agency's name.
- Long contracts (12 months or more) with no exit clause.
- Reports full of reach and impressions with no leads or sales.
- A proposal sent before they asked about your business.
- No case studies, or case studies with no numbers.
- A different person every time you call.
- Hidden markups on ad spend or outsourced work. Armanino, an accounting and consulting firm, notes that agencies that outsource work often add around 30% when they pass those costs along. A markup is fine if it is disclosed.

## Contract terms to check before you sign

| Term | What to look for |
| --- | --- |
| Scope | Specific deliverables, channels and meeting rhythm |
| Fees | Monthly fee, setup fee, and how ad spend is billed |
| Term and exit | Month to month or 3 months minimum, 30 day notice |
| Ownership | You own ad accounts, analytics, website, content and data |
| Reporting | Which metrics, how often, and dashboard access |
| Handover | Agency returns all logins, files and assets at no cost |

## Quick answers to common marketing rules

- **The 5 Cs of marketing:** company, customers, competitors, collaborators and climate. Use them to size up your market before you hire.
- **The 40-40-20 rule:** in direct marketing, 40% of results come from the audience, 40% from the offer and 20% from the creative. Agencies that focus only on design are working on the smallest lever.
- **The 3-7-27 rule:** a branding idea that people need to see a brand 3 times to notice it, 7 times to remember it and 27 times to act. It is a rule of thumb, not research, but it explains why one month of ads rarely tells the full story.

## FAQ

## What are the most important factors in selecting an advertising agency?

The most important factors are proof of results for similar businesses, a clear written plan, the people assigned to your account, transparent pricing, and your ownership of every account and data source. Chemistry matters too. You will talk to this team every week.

## How many agencies should I talk to?

Talk to three. One is not a comparison, and more than four turns into a long process with little new information. Use the same scorecard for each so you compare the same things.

## Should I choose a local agency?

A local agency helps if you rely on local search, Google Maps or in person events, since it knows the market. For national ecommerce or software, location matters less than experience in your model.

## What should a marketing agency proposal include?

A summary of your goals, the channels it recommends and why, deliverables, a 90 day timeline, targets, reporting, team members, fees and contract terms. If any of those are missing, ask for them in writing.

## See how Lucid Brands measures up

Lucid Brands is a Phoenix marketing agency. Every client owns their accounts, gets a named strategist and sees leads and revenue in every report. Run us through this scorecard, starting with a free paid media audit (https://lucidbrands.agency/media-audit) or website audit (https://lucidbrands.agency/website-audit). You can also browse our case studies (https://lucidbrands.agency/case-studies).

Your path to lucidity

## Get Started With a Free Website Audit

Not sure where to begin? Start with a free website audit. Our team analyzes your website's SEO, speed, content and user experience to identify what to improve first.

Explore More

## Related Resources

### AI Marketing Agency: What They Do and How to Choose One

What an AI marketing agency does, how it differs from a traditional agency, the services to expect, typical costs, questions to ask, signs of AI washing, and when AI support makes sense.

Read More
https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/ai-marketing-agency

### Full-Service Marketing Agency: What's Included and Is It Right for You

What a full service marketing agency does, which services are included, how pricing works, full service vs specialist vs in house, questions to ask, red flags and what the first 90 days look like.

Read More
https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/full-service-marketing-agency

### Growth Marketing Agency: What to Expect

What a growth marketing agency does, how it differs from performance and full service agencies, pricing tiers from named sources, agency vs in house vs fractional, a first 90 days plan, questions to ask, red flags and how to measure results.

Read More
https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/growth-marketing-agency

All Working With an Agency Resources (https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency)

## Privacy Choices

We measure visits and personalize ads as you browse. Your choice below decides whether that keeps happening, and you can change it any time. Our website provider counts visits without cookies.

Privacy policy (https://lucidbrands.agency/privacy-policy)

## Structured data

```json
[
  {
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BlogPosting",
    "@id": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency#article",
    "url": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency",
    "headline": "What to Look For in a Marketing Agency",
    "description": "What to look for in a marketing agency: 10 criteria, the questions to ask, red flags, contract terms to check, and a free scorecard to compare agencies.",
    "keywords": "what to look for in a marketing agency",
    "datePublished": "2026-11-14",
    "dateModified": "2026-11-14",
    "mainEntityOfPage": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency",
    "articleSection": "Working With an Agency",
    "author": {
      "@type": "Organization",
      "name": "Lucid Brands Team",
      "url": "https://lucidbrands.agency/about"
    },
    "publisher": {
      "@id": "https://lucidbrands.agency/#organization"
    },
    "isPartOf": {
      "@id": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency#webpage"
    }
  },
  {
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "FAQPage",
    "mainEntity": [
      {
        "@type": "Question",
        "name": "What are the most important factors in selecting an advertising agency?",
        "acceptedAnswer": {
          "@type": "Answer",
          "text": "The most important factors are proof of results for similar businesses, a clear written plan, the people assigned to your account, transparent pricing, and your ownership of every account and data source. Chemistry matters too. You will talk to this team every week."
        }
      },
      {
        "@type": "Question",
        "name": "How many agencies should I talk to?",
        "acceptedAnswer": {
          "@type": "Answer",
          "text": "Talk to three. One is not a comparison, and more than four turns into a long process with little new information. Use the same scorecard for each so you compare the same things."
        }
      },
      {
        "@type": "Question",
        "name": "Should I choose a local agency?",
        "acceptedAnswer": {
          "@type": "Answer",
          "text": "A local agency helps if you rely on local search, Google Maps or in person events, since it knows the market. For national ecommerce or software, location matters less than experience in your model."
        }
      },
      {
        "@type": "Question",
        "name": "What should a marketing agency proposal include?",
        "acceptedAnswer": {
          "@type": "Answer",
          "text": "A summary of your goals, the channels it recommends and why, deliverables, a 90 day timeline, targets, reporting, team members, fees and contract terms. If any of those are missing, ask for them in writing."
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
    "itemListElement": [
      {
        "@type": "ListItem",
        "position": 1,
        "name": "Home",
        "item": "https://lucidbrands.agency/"
      },
      {
        "@type": "ListItem",
        "position": 2,
        "name": "Resources",
        "item": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources"
      },
      {
        "@type": "ListItem",
        "position": 3,
        "name": "Working With an Agency",
        "item": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency"
      },
      {
        "@type": "ListItem",
        "position": 4,
        "name": "What to Look For in a Marketing Agency",
        "item": "https://lucidbrands.agency/resources/working-with-an-agency/what-to-look-for-in-a-marketing-agency"
      }
    ]
  }
]
```